Some experiences should stay human.  —  A 501(c)(3) preserving authentic Native American + Southwestern silversmithing.
Co‑Op
A Field Guide to Southwest Jewelry · by Mateo James

Is It Real? How to Buy Authentic Native American Jewelry

← Field Guide

Federal law is on your side — here's how to use it.

There's a quiet problem in the Southwestern jewelry world: overseas factories turning out imitation "Native" jewelry — carved fake Zuni fetishes, mass-stamped "Navajo-style" silver, even pieces labeled to imply they were made on the reservation when they never were. It hurts the authentic artists whose work and heritage are being counterfeited, and it costs buyers who think they're bringing home the real thing.

The good news: there's a federal law built specifically to protect you. Here's what it is, and how to shop with confidence.

The Indian Arts and Crafts Act

The Indian Arts and Crafts Act of 1990 (Public Law 101-644) is a truth-in-advertising law. In plain terms: it is illegal to sell any product in a way that falsely suggests it was made by a Native American, an Indian tribe, or a Native artisan when it wasn't. The law is administered by the Indian Arts and Crafts Board at the U.S. Department of the Interior.

That means a seller can't call a piece "Navajo," "Zuni," "Hopi," or "Native American made" unless it genuinely is. If they do, they're breaking federal law — and you can report it.

In New Mexico, there's an extra layer. The New Mexico Indian Arts and Crafts Sales Act goes further than the federal law: it requires the seller to disclose, in writing, the materials used in a piece. If they don't and you find out the materials weren't as represented, you may be entitled to a refund. (NM Attorney General: nmag.gov · 1-800-678-1508.)

How to buy authentic — ask for a real receipt

The single best protection is a written receipt that documents what you're buying. A reputable seller will happily provide one. Ask that it list:

  • The artist's name and Tribal affiliation
  • The mine of origin for the stone (if turquoise)
  • Whether the stone is natural, stabilized, or treated
  • Where it was purchased, the price, the date, and the seller's business address

If a seller won't put those details in writing, that's your answer.

Know your turquoise — natural vs. treated

Most turquoise on the market has been altered in some way. None of these are "fake" — but you deserve to know which you're paying for:

  • Natural — cut and polished, nothing added. The rarest and most valuable.
  • Stabilized — a colorless resin is forced into the stone under pressure to harden it. Very common, and honest when disclosed.
  • Treated — lightly oiled or waxed to deepen color.
  • Enhanced — a process that darkens color.
  • Dyed / Blocked — pigment added, or chips bonded with epoxy into a block for cutting. The furthest from natural.

Value comes down to color, clarity, and matrix (the veining). The most prized natural turquoise shows a fine, even "spider web" matrix. Legendary American mines include Lone Mountain, Number Eight, Lander Blue, and Bisbee; the most widely sold today are Arizona's Sleeping Beauty and Kingman.

The bottom line

Buy from people who tell you the truth — the artist, the tribe, the stone, in writing. When they do, you're not just getting a beautiful piece; you're supporting the living tradition it comes from. And if someone's passing off a fake, the law gives you a way to fight back.

References